[Click the above picture to see a larger view]
As a reviewer in several journals in the field of Catalysis, I have recommended to reject nearly 80% of manuscripts (of about 30 manuscripts) which was sent to me by the editors in the last two years. Most of the manuscripts submitted were from universities in China. I do not know, if this is a coincidence or because so many manuscripts was submitted from the Chinese university. However, I also found that the quality of some manuscripts submitted from leading universities in Europe was low.
The following are the reasons why I do not accept manuscripts for publication:
– Originality. Usually in a paper that is not original, the results is very easy to predict.
– Speculation. Discussion and conclusion are not supported by the complete set of accurate data. Because of that the jump into conclusion statement was found in the manuscript.
– Logic. The analytical technique used is not appropriate, nor logic in analyzing the data.